The Mitchell Report
I've waited long and hard before commenting on the Mitchell Report. Like most fans, I was shocked by the scale of the report, and yet not shocked at the same time(if that makes sense). I'm also a little concerned about the lack of corroborating evidence for much of the report but more about that later
Many Americans may not understand or appreciate the respect Irish people have for Senator Mitchell. He played a key role in the Northern Ireland peace process and there is no doubt that without his work, terrorism could still be a force in a corner of this small island. many people probably owe their lives to him without realising it and he is far more worthy of the Noble peace prize then some born again has been Presidential candidate.
The fact that much of his report into the game is based on hearsay is disturbing. Too many innocent people around the world have been convicted on bad evidence and incompetent investigative work, the West Memphis 3, Guildford 4 and Birmingham 6 all spring to mind for starters.
However, If this report had been writen by anyone else, I'd be majorily concerned, the fact that it is Sen Mitchell gives me a lot of confidence that what he is saying is correct. Let's be honest with ourselves here as well, we've seen the bulked up players, the sudden changes over a summer in performance, the records being smashed, c'mon, be honest here, we all knew something wasn't right
So who's to blame, the players, undoubtably take the bulk of the blame, their the ones who stuck needles in their arms. Likewise the clubs have to take responsibility for their employees actions. You have to wonder, how many exectives and owners knew players were juicing up and turned a blind eye. The union did not condon juicing but certainly did not go out of it's way to prevent it either. Bud Selig and the people who run the game have to take responsibility also, the buck ultimately stops at their desk. It doesn't matter if they didn't know, they should have known.
And what about us, the fans, do we share responsibility?. Most definately we do. Who cheered when someone hit a homer in a play off game, or when Bonds hit a special into centre field, or a pitcher's heat couldn't be handled by the batters?. We did and did we care?, as long as it was one of our players doing great things, probably not. Like Bud Sellig, it didn't matter if we didn't know, we should have known and we should have shouted oh so louder
What's happened has happened so where do we go from here?. I believe what is now required is an amnesty for all players. Let them come forward between here and the season opener and admit they cheated, if they indeed did. Take no action against them, this is about simply getting things out in the open but put an * on their records for all times. However, if a player does not come forward and further evidence comes to light to prove they did cheat, then let justice be swift and merciless and treat these people in the same manner as Pete Rose, lifetime ban, strip them of their pensions and let them become pariahs for all time
Secondly, robust drug testing policies are needed, probably in line with WADA rules. If it is good enough for every other sport in the world, why not baseball?
Players too need support, I know some serious athletes are reluctant to get medical treatment because they may fail a test subsequently. A players health is the main priority here, so if a doctor recomends medically something that would otherwise be banned, let the player get a 2nd opinion from MLB sponsered medical teams and if deemed the correct course of action, let them take the remedy
As for players caught juicing, we can all make a mistate so I don't believe punishment for the first offence should be excessive, 20-50 games and a fine is probably sufficient(and an * on that seasons stats). Get caught again and a season ban, get caught a 3rd time, and you're out
Clubs too need to be punished, they are responsible for their players behavious. So if a player fails a test after a game they've won, fine the club and strip them of their victory, regardless of where in the season it's at. If it persists, then if needed, ban the team for the rest of the season
Hopefully this will be the beginning of the end of the jucing era and 2008 will allow us to start afresh, if not, I fear for the future of this great game